credit and income
← Back to search

Credit Scores and a Mortgage File

QUICK SUMMARY

A mortgage file usually pulls scores from all three major bureaus, the guideline picks which score controls, and that score sits beside payment history, debts, and the down payment as one input to the decision.

There isn't one minimum credit score for every mortgage, and that's the honest answer to "what score do I need to buy a house." It depends on the loan program, on what the automated underwriting system says about your whole file, and on the lender. With us, the one company minimum is 580 on FHA loans. Fannie Mae's Desktop Underwriter no longer has a minimum score for new casefiles, Freddie Mac doesn't require one when LPA returns an Accept, VA doesn't set one, and USDA doesn't print one. Texas down payment assistance programs start at 620. And your score is only one line in a file the underwriter reads in full.

Below I'll explain where the mortgage score comes from, which score counts when there are three of them, how each program uses it, what else on the report matters, and what tends to help or backfire before you apply. I keep the agency rule, the automated underwriting rule, the program rule and our company rule separate, because mixing them up is where most of the confusing advice online comes from.

Quick answer by loan type

  • FHA. HUD's handbook ties lower scores to lower maximum financing. Our company minimum on every FHA loan is 580, including manually underwritten files. Details are in FHA credit score requirements.
  • Conventional (Fannie Mae). No minimum score on DU casefiles created on or after Nov 16, 2025. Manually underwritten loans keep minimums of 620 for fixed rate and 640 for ARMs.
  • Conventional (Freddie Mac). No minimum Indicator Score when LPA returns an Accept. Manually underwritten loans follow Freddie's Exhibit 25.
  • VA. No VA-set minimum. The lender reviews the whole credit history.
  • USDA. No single number in the regulation. A GUS Accept means USDA treats the credit as acceptable.
  • Texas DPA. TSAHC and TDHCA start at 620, and TSAHC asks for 640 on conventional loans. See down payment assistance in Texas.

Sources for each of these are below. If your score is under 620 and you're hoping for a conventional loan, or you don't have a score at all, ask me how this applies to your file before you assume either way.

Where the mortgage score comes from

Most mortgage files use a tri-merge credit report. I order a single report that pulls your files from Equifax, Experian and TransUnion and shows the accounts from all three side by side, with a score from each bureau.

Those scores come from specific scoring model versions the agencies accept. Fannie Mae still requires the classic FICO versions from each bureau for DU and manually underwritten loans, and lists VantageScore 4.0 as eligible for lenders set up to deliver it (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-5.1-01). Freddie Mac opened VantageScore 4.0 to all sellers on Sept 9, 2026, and still requires classic FICO on manually underwritten loans (Freddie Mac Bulletin 2026-H). For FHA, HUD Mortgagee Letter 2026-11 changes the credit score rules only for case numbers assigned on or after Jan 1, 2027 (HUD ML 2026-11). Until then, the current FHA rules apply. Which model a file uses depends on the program, the lender and the date, so ask me which model your file will use rather than assuming a newer one is in play.

The practical point: the score on a mortgage report is often different from the score in your bank app or on a free credit monitoring site. Those apps commonly show a different model, and sometimes a different bureau. Both numbers can be accurate. They're measuring the same report with different formulas. That's why I'd rather read your mortgage report than guess from an app.

Which score the file uses

With one borrower and three scores, the usual practice is to take the middle score. Line the three up from lowest to highest, and the one in between is the score the file uses. The highest is set aside, and so is the lowest. If only two bureaus return a score, guidelines commonly use the lower of the two. If only one bureau or none returns a score, the file may need a program that allows limited or non-traditional credit, and that's a conversation to have with me directly.

With two or more borrowers, each borrower gets their own representative score first, and then the program says how those combine. FHA uses the lowest decision score among the borrowers (HUD 4000.1 II.A.1.b.ii(A)(3)). Fannie Mae uses the average of the borrowers' median scores to set eligibility on manually underwritten loans (B3-5.1-01). Freddie Mac lets the seller choose among three methods when a minimum score applies (Freddie Mac Guide 5203.2(e)). The guide in the file names the method. Scores are selected by rule, so a spouse's strong score doesn't cover for a weak one through a household blend unless the program's own method does that.

How the score is used

The score does two separate jobs: eligibility and pricing.

Job 1: eligibility, layer by layer

Here's where each program stands today, with the agency rule, the automated underwriting rule and our company rule kept separate.

  • Conventional, Fannie Mae. DU loan casefiles have no minimum credit score. Fannie Mae removed the 620 minimum for new DU loan casefiles created on or after Nov 16, 2025, and DU now applies its own credit risk assessment instead (Selling Guide Announcement SEL-2025-09; B3-5.1-01). The lender still has to order the required scores. Manually underwritten Fannie Mae loans keep a minimum of 620 for fixed-rate loans and 640 for ARMs, with more detail in Fannie Mae's Eligibility Matrix.
  • Conventional, Freddie Mac. When LPA returns an Accept, Freddie Mac doesn't require a minimum Indicator Score, because LPA has already assessed creditworthiness (Bulletin 2026-H; Guide 5203.2). Manually underwritten Freddie Mac loans have to meet the minimums in Guide Exhibit 25.
  • FHA. HUD's handbook sets the floor and ties lower scores to lower maximum financing (HUD 4000.1 II.A.1.b.ii(A)(3) and II.A.2.b.i). Our company minimum on every FHA loan is 580, including manually underwritten files, so we don't offer FHA financing below 580. We do offer FHA manual underwriting, but it isn't automatic: the file has to meet HUD's manual standards. See automated underwriting for how the systems decide which files need a manual review.
  • VA. VA doesn't set a minimum credit score. The lender reviews the whole credit history under VA's credit standards (VA Lenders Handbook M26-7, Chapter 4; VA lender training, credit underwriting).
  • USDA guaranteed. USDA's rule asks for a credit history that shows ability and willingness to repay, supported by an acceptable credit score and credit report, but it doesn't print one minimum score (7 CFR 3555.151(i)). When the Guaranteed Underwriting System, GUS, issues an Accept, USDA treats the credit as acceptable without a separate score validation. Manually underwritten USDA files get a deeper credit review as scores get lower (HB-1-3555, Chapter 10).

Lender overlays are a separate layer from everything above. Many lenders set their own minimum scores, which is why two lenders can answer the same file differently. Other than the 580 FHA minimum, our company follows the agency and automated underwriting rules without adding score minimums of its own. How any of this applies to a specific file, especially a low score on a conventional or USDA loan, is something I'll check on your actual findings. State down payment programs such as TSAHC and TDHCA set their own score requirements, covered in their own articles.

Job 2: pricing

On conventional loans, the score is one of the inputs in loan-level price adjustments, which are charges tied to risk factors like score and loan-to-value. A higher score can mean a better price on the rate sheet for the same loan. Mortgage insurance companies also price by score. Those tables change and I don't reprint them here, because a table from last year can misstate this year's price. If you're close to a score break, it's worth asking whether a small improvement before you lock would change your options.

What the underwriter reads besides the score

The underwriter reads the report itself, line by line. That reading is where many files are actually decided.

  • Payment history: late payments, and how recent they are. A mortgage or rent late payment is usually weighed more heavily than a late payment on a store card.
  • Collections, charge-offs, judgments and tax liens, and whether the program requires them to be paid, explained or counted as a debt. See buying a house with collections.
  • Bankruptcy, foreclosure, short sale or deed-in-lieu, each with its own waiting period measured from a specific date.
  • Balances and minimum payments, which go into the debt-to-income ratio.
  • Inquiries, and whether any of them opened a new account that's missing from the report or the application.
  • Disputes, which can affect whether automated findings are available.
  • Federal debt. FHA and other government programs check CAIVRS, a federal database of delinquent federal debts like a defaulted federal student loan or an SBA loan.

Here's how the score and the report can pull in different directions. A buyer has a middle score that clears the program's floor and an old collection the score has already absorbed. The score is fine. The collection may still need to be paid, explained or counted, depending on the program. The buyer who only watches the score misses the collection. The buyer who only worries about the collection misses that the score already works. When something needs explaining, a short, factual letter of explanation usually does the job.

Credit inquiries and shopping lenders

A lot of people put off talking to a lender because they're afraid of "dinging" their score. Here's what the CFPB says: within a 45-day window, multiple credit checks from mortgage lenders are recorded as a single inquiry, because lenders know you're only buying one home. Checking your own credit doesn't affect your scores at all (CFPB, What happens when a mortgage lender checks my credit?).

That grace applies to mortgage inquiries. A new car loan or a store card opened during the process is a different story, both for the score and for your ratios. The underwriter may also ask about recent inquiries from other creditors to make sure no new debt is missing from the application.

You may also remember getting a flood of calls and texts right after a lender pulled your credit. Those were "trigger leads." The Homebuyers Privacy Protection Act limits them: since March 5, 2026, a credit bureau generally can't sell your mortgage inquiry to another company unless it's a firm offer and that company has your authorization, already holds or services your current mortgage, or is a bank or credit union where you have an account (Public Law 119-36, amending FCRA section 604(c)). You can still opt out of prescreened offers at the bureaus if you'd like fewer of them.

Authorized-user accounts

Being an authorized user on a parent's or spouse's card can put that account's history on your report. Whether the mortgage file credits it depends on the program and the automated findings. Some automated systems consider authorized-user tradelines, and some guidelines tell the underwriter to look closer when the account belongs to someone else. If most of your history comes from authorized-user accounts, expect the underwriter to ask about it.

Errors and disputes

If something on the report is wrong, you have the right under the Fair Credit Reporting Act to dispute it with the credit bureau, and the bureau has to investigate. Free copies of your reports are available at AnnualCreditReport.com, the site the federal government directs consumers to.

A dispute on a true account can cause trouble during the loan, because some automated systems won't issue findings with certain open disputes on the report. The lender may ask you to remove the dispute, which can change the score. A dispute on an account that's actually wrong should stay until the bureau corrects it.

When a correction has been made, or a balance has been paid down, a lender can sometimes request a rapid rescore. The lender sends documentation through its credit vendor, the bureaus update the account, and a new score is produced faster than waiting for the next normal reporting cycle. A rapid rescore updates accurate information. A true late payment stays on the report, and a letter to the lender won't remove it.

What tends to move a score, and what tends to backfire

Scores respond mostly to payment history and to how much of your available revolving credit you're using. Paying a credit card balance down before the statement closes can lower the reported utilization. Making every payment on time keeps the history clean.

Changes made right before a mortgage often backfire. Opening a new card or loan to build credit adds a new account, a hard inquiry and sometimes a new payment that lands in the ratio. Closing old cards can raise utilization by shrinking the available credit. Paying an old collection can change the date of activity on the account, and on some scoring models that can lower the score in the short run. Each of these is worth deciding with me looking at your report, instead of following a tip from social media.

Fictional example

This example is made up to show how the rules apply.

Dante and Keisha are buying in Benbrook. Dante's three scores are 640, 655 and 671, so his middle score is 655. Keisha's are 598, 611 and 604, so her middle score is 604. On an FHA loan, the lowest middle score among the borrowers counts, so the file is decided at 604. That clears our 580 FHA minimum. It doesn't meet the 620 that TSAHC and TDHCA ask for, so if they want state assistance, the plan is either to raise Keisha's score first or to look at whether Dante could qualify on his own. Keisha's bank app shows a higher number than her mortgage score, because it uses a different model. Whether they're approved still comes down to underwriting their income, debts and the rest of the report.

Common myths

  • "You need a 620 to buy a house." That's an old conventional rule of thumb. Today it depends on the program and the findings, as laid out above.
  • "My app score is my mortgage score." Usually not. Mortgage files use specific models from all three bureaus.
  • "Talking to lenders will wreck my score." Mortgage inquiries within 45 days count as one.
  • "A great score guarantees approval." Income, debts, assets and the rest of the report still have to work.
  • "Paying off every collection will raise my score." Not always, and sometimes it isn't required. Ask before you pay.

Before the call

  • If you've pulled your own reports recently, keep them handy. Note anything you think is wrong.
  • Gather any paperwork for past bankruptcies, foreclosures or short sales, including the discharge or completion date.
  • Write down any accounts you share with a spouse or family member, and any cards where you're an authorized user.
  • Hold off on new credit applications, card closures and collection payoffs until we've read the report together.
  • If you have no credit cards or loans at all, gather your rent, utility or insurance payment records going back as far as you can in case a non-traditional credit path comes up. The program sets what it accepts, and I'll tell you how it applies to your file.

Next step

The fastest way to know where you stand is to read your actual mortgage report with the right program in mind. I'll show you which score controls, what else on the report matters, and whether anything is worth fixing before you write an offer. Book a call, or when you're ready, start an application.

Related questions

Sources

Links checked Oct 21, 2026.

About the author: McKade Lively, NMLS 2704474, American Pacific Mortgage Corporation dba True North Home Loans, NMLS 1850.

Equal Housing Opportunity.

Last reviewed: Oct 2026

‍

McKade Lively, NMLS #2704474. Equal Housing Opportunity.